# External Review Worksheet — Profiling Classification & Public Safeguards

Schema version: wsmusings.external-review-worksheet.v1
Package ID: `investigation-package:v740:profiling-classification-safeguards`
Source Research Object: `research-object:v739:profiling-classification-safeguards`
Evidence status: EVIDENCE_ACQUISITION_INCOMPLETE
Evaluation status: NOT_EXTERNALLY_EVALUATED

## Review tasks

1. Restate the central question without strengthening its language.
   Response:

2. Trace at least three propositions to exact records and locators.
   Response:

3. Identify one unsupported assumption.
   Response:

4. Identify or propose contrary evidence.
   Response:

5. Reproduce one calculation or comparison.
   Response:

6. Explain why the package does not yet establish causation.
   Response:

7. Export a citation-complete review worksheet.
   Response:

## Evaluator disposition

- [ ] TRACEABILITY_CONFIRMED
- [ ] TRACEABILITY_GAP_FOUND
- [ ] MATERIAL_SOURCE_GAP_FOUND
- [ ] COMPARISON_DESIGN_GAP_FOUND
- [ ] ALTERNATIVE_EXPLANATION_MISSING
- [ ] REPRODUCTION_PASS
- [ ] REPRODUCTION_FAIL
- [ ] LANGUAGE_OVERSTATES_EVIDENCE
- [ ] NO_MATERIAL_DEFECT_LOCATED

## Citation register

- Package: /api/v1/investigation-packages/profiling-classification-safeguards.json
- Research Object: /research/objects/profiling-classification-safeguards/
- Claim matrix: /downloads/investigation-packages/v7.40/profiling-classification-safeguards/claim-evidence-matrix.csv
- Source locators: /downloads/investigation-packages/v7.40/profiling-classification-safeguards/source-locator-register.csv

## Boundary

Evaluation status is separate from evidence status. This worksheet cannot automatically produce CLAIM_VERIFIED, CLAIM_FALSE, CAUSATION_CONFIRMED, PUBLICATION_APPROVED.

No browser-local private note or Workspace record is included in this committed worksheet.