{
  "schemaVersion": "wsmusings.automated-evidence-assessment.v1",
  "assessmentEngineVersion": "wsmusings.automated-evidence-quality-engine.v1",
  "assessmentId": "assessment:v716:464fb9633f0b0c170adf",
  "assessmentTimestamp": "2026-08-24T00:00:00Z",
  "timestampPolicy": "Release-normalized timestamp; excluded from rule inputs and stable for identical v7.16 builds.",
  "object": {
    "objectId": "education-science-knowledge",
    "objectType": "CATEGORY",
    "title": "Education, Science & Knowledge",
    "k": null,
    "associatedObjectIds": [
      "education-science-knowledge"
    ]
  },
  "claim": {
    "claimId": "claim:v715:e43e89bfd68a83281ede",
    "exactLanguage": "Federal law assigns the Institute of Education Sciences a mission to provide reliable information about U.S. education condition and progress, access to educational opportunities, and program effectiveness; this mission does not establish the effectiveness of any particular program.",
    "scope": "Institute of Education Sciences statutory mission; United States; federal law in force through 2026; no program-level effectiveness finding.",
    "exclusions": [
      "United States",
      "federal law in force through 2026",
      "no program-level effectiveness finding."
    ],
    "jurisdiction": "United States",
    "applicablePopulation": "Students, educators, and education policymakers within the federal statutory scope",
    "relevantTimePeriod": "2002-11-05/2026-08-24"
  },
  "evidence": {
    "supportingEvidence": [
      {
        "evidenceRecordId": "evidence:v715:0074fa9eda8c74982dea",
        "researchObjectId": "education-science-knowledge",
        "claimId": "claim:v715:e43e89bfd68a83281ede",
        "claimText": "Federal law assigns the Institute of Education Sciences a mission to provide reliable information about U.S. education condition and progress, access to educational opportunities, and program effectiveness; this mission does not establish the effectiveness of any particular program.",
        "claimScope": "Institute of Education Sciences statutory mission; United States; federal law in force through 2026; no program-level effectiveness finding.",
        "jurisdiction": "United States",
        "applicablePopulation": "Students, educators, and education policymakers within the federal statutory scope",
        "relevantTimePeriod": "2002-11-05/2026-08-24",
        "sourceId": "source:v715:388ea19e827e867332fc",
        "sourceTitle": "Education Sciences Reform Act of 2002, Pub. L. 107-279",
        "sourceAuthorOrIssuingAuthority": "United States Congress",
        "publisher": "Congress.gov",
        "sourceType": "STATUTE",
        "canonicalUrl": "https://www.congress.gov/107/plaws/publ279/PLAW-107publ279.pdf",
        "publicationDate": "2002-11-05",
        "accessDate": "2026-08-24",
        "exactLocatorType": "STATUTORY_PROVISION",
        "exactLocatorValue": "Pub. L. 107-279 § 111(b)(1), 116 Stat. 1945; 20 U.S.C. § 9511",
        "atomicUrlRationale": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "extractOrParaphrase": "Paraphrase: IES is directed to provide national leadership and reliable information on education condition and progress, opportunity access, and program effectiveness.",
        "quotationStatus": "PARAPHRASE",
        "evidenceDirection": "CONFIRMATORY",
        "applicability": "APPLICABLE",
        "currency": "CURRENT_AS_CODIFIED",
        "authorityAssessment": "PRIMARY_FEDERAL_STATUTE",
        "methodologicalLimitation": "The statute establishes an institutional mission; it does not prove that every education program is effective or accessible.",
        "conflictOrContradictionStatus": "NO_MATERIAL_CONTRADICTION_IDENTIFIED_BY_AUTOMATED_PRECHECK",
        "counterevidenceLink": "LINKED_WITHIN_CLAIM_RECORD",
        "reviewerDisposition": "NOT_EVALUATED",
        "reconciliationState": "NOT_EVALUATED",
        "provenance": {
          "authoringOrigin": "SYSTEM_CURATED_FROM_PRIMARY_SOURCE",
          "sourceAccess": "PUBLIC_OFFICIAL_URL",
          "modelOutputUsedAsEvidence": false,
          "automatedAssessmentPerformed": false
        },
        "createdAt": "2026-08-24T00:00:00Z",
        "updatedAt": "2026-08-24T00:00:00Z",
        "schemaVersion": "wsmusings.evidence-pilot.v1"
      }
    ],
    "disconfirmatoryEvidence": [],
    "mixedEvidence": [],
    "contextOnlyEvidence": [],
    "structuredNoMatchRecords": [
      {
        "evidenceRecordId": "evidence:v715:eb2be8fb655731f27ffc",
        "researchObjectId": "education-science-knowledge",
        "claimId": "claim:v715:e43e89bfd68a83281ede",
        "claimText": "Federal law assigns the Institute of Education Sciences a mission to provide reliable information about U.S. education condition and progress, access to educational opportunities, and program effectiveness; this mission does not establish the effectiveness of any particular program.",
        "claimScope": "Institute of Education Sciences statutory mission; United States; federal law in force through 2026; no program-level effectiveness finding.",
        "jurisdiction": "United States",
        "applicablePopulation": "Students, educators, and education policymakers within the federal statutory scope",
        "relevantTimePeriod": "2002-11-05/2026-08-24",
        "sourceId": "NO_MATCH",
        "sourceTitle": "NO_MATCH — bounded official-source search",
        "sourceAuthorOrIssuingAuthority": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "publisher": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "sourceType": "SEARCH_ATTEMPT",
        "canonicalUrl": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "publicationDate": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "accessDate": "2026-08-24",
        "exactLocatorType": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "exactLocatorValue": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "atomicUrlRationale": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "extractOrParaphrase": "No qualifying primary source was sought or found that could convert the institutional mission into a general finding that all education programs are effective or accessible.",
        "quotationStatus": "PARAPHRASE",
        "evidenceDirection": "NO_MATCH",
        "applicability": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "currency": "NOT_ASSESSED",
        "authorityAssessment": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
        "methodologicalLimitation": "The search was intentionally bounded to the pilot claim and does not constitute a systematic review.",
        "conflictOrContradictionStatus": "NO_MATCH_IS_NOT_DISCONFIRMATION",
        "counterevidenceLink": "LINKED_WITHIN_CLAIM_RECORD",
        "reviewerDisposition": "NOT_EVALUATED",
        "reconciliationState": "NOT_EVALUATED",
        "provenance": {
          "authoringOrigin": "SYSTEM_CURATED_FROM_PRIMARY_SOURCE",
          "sourceAccess": "PUBLIC_OFFICIAL_URL",
          "modelOutputUsedAsEvidence": false,
          "automatedAssessmentPerformed": false
        },
        "createdAt": "2026-08-24T00:00:00Z",
        "updatedAt": "2026-08-24T00:00:00Z",
        "schemaVersion": "wsmusings.evidence-pilot.v1",
        "searchAttempt": {
          "searchDate": "2026-08-24",
          "searchScope": "Official federal statutes and IES mission materials",
          "searchStrategy": "Checked ESRA mission language for a source-specific proposition proving universal program effectiveness or access.",
          "sourceClassesExamined": [
            "FEDERAL_STATUTE",
            "OFFICIAL_AGENCY_MATERIAL"
          ],
          "limitations": "The search was intentionally bounded to the pilot claim and does not constitute a systematic review.",
          "anotherSearchWarranted": true
        }
      }
    ],
    "exactSourceLocators": [
      {
        "evidenceRecordId": "evidence:v715:0074fa9eda8c74982dea",
        "sourceId": "source:v715:388ea19e827e867332fc",
        "sourceTitle": "Education Sciences Reform Act of 2002, Pub. L. 107-279",
        "locatorType": "STATUTORY_PROVISION",
        "locatorValue": "Pub. L. 107-279 § 111(b)(1), 116 Stat. 1945; 20 U.S.C. § 9511",
        "direction": "CONFIRMATORY"
      }
    ],
    "missingEvidence": [],
    "unresolvedRelationships": 0,
    "unresolvedMechanisms": 0
  },
  "automatedCritic": {
    "status": "AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE",
    "automatedAssessment": false,
    "findings": [
      {
        "check": "overbreadth",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "sourceApplicability",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "sourceCurrency",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "sourceIndependence",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "locatorSufficiency",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "conflictingEvidence",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "alternativeExplanations",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "causalOverstatement",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "populationOrJurisdictionMismatch",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "unsupportedGeneralization",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      },
      {
        "check": "missingLimitations",
        "status": "PASS",
        "finding": "The deterministic structural rule found no blocker; this is not human or substantive validation."
      }
    ],
    "semantics": "Deterministic structural checks only; not deterministic evidence assessment, expert approval, truth, reliability, credibility, confidence, or probability."
  },
  "componentMetrics": {
    "locatorCompleteness": {
      "metricId": "LOCATOR_COMPLETENESS",
      "numerator": 1,
      "denominator": 1,
      "range": "0/1–1/1",
      "formula": "count satisfying the named rule / count to which the rule applies",
      "interpretation": "Exact locators present for applicable evidence records.",
      "limitations": "Does not assess whether a source proves the claim.",
      "publicationBlocking": true
    },
    "sourceCoverage": {
      "metricId": "SOURCE_COVERAGE",
      "numerator": 1,
      "denominator": 1,
      "range": "0/1–1/1",
      "formula": "count satisfying the named rule / count to which the rule applies",
      "interpretation": "Presence of at least one confirmatory record.",
      "limitations": "Official status does not automatically confirm a claim.",
      "publicationBlocking": true
    },
    "counterevidenceHandling": {
      "metricId": "COUNTEREVIDENCE_HANDLING",
      "numerator": 1,
      "denominator": 1,
      "range": "0/1–1/1",
      "formula": "count satisfying the named rule / count to which the rule applies",
      "interpretation": "Visibility of at least one countervailing or limiting record.",
      "limitations": "Visibility does not resolve a conflict.",
      "publicationBlocking": true
    },
    "claimToEvidenceTraceability": {
      "metricId": "CLAIM_TO_EVIDENCE_TRACEABILITY",
      "numerator": 2,
      "denominator": 2,
      "range": "0/2–2/2",
      "formula": "count satisfying the named rule / count to which the rule applies",
      "interpretation": "Evidence records refer to the bounded claim.",
      "limitations": "Traceability is not support.",
      "publicationBlocking": true
    },
    "mechanismResolution": {
      "metricId": "MECHANISM_RESOLUTION",
      "numerator": 1,
      "denominator": 1,
      "range": "0/1–1/1",
      "formula": "count satisfying the named rule / count to which the rule applies",
      "interpretation": "Required mechanism resolved or not applicable.",
      "limitations": "Resolution requires qualifying direct evidence.",
      "publicationBlocking": true
    },
    "relationshipResolution": {
      "metricId": "RELATIONSHIP_RESOLUTION",
      "numerator": 1,
      "denominator": 1,
      "range": "0/1–1/1",
      "formula": "count satisfying the named rule / count to which the rule applies",
      "interpretation": "Required relationship resolved or not applicable.",
      "limitations": "Computational closeness cannot resolve relationship type.",
      "publicationBlocking": true
    },
    "missingEvidenceBurden": {
      "metricId": "MISSING_EVIDENCE_BURDEN",
      "value": 0,
      "range": "0–unbounded count",
      "formula": "count of explicitly required evidence records still missing",
      "interpretation": "Higher values indicate more missing mandatory evidence.",
      "limitations": "Absence is not falsity.",
      "publicationBlocking": true
    },
    "criticPrecheckCompletion": {
      "metricId": "CRITIC_PRECHECK_COMPLETION",
      "numerator": 11,
      "denominator": 11,
      "range": "0/11–11/11",
      "formula": "count satisfying the named rule / count to which the rule applies",
      "interpretation": "Deterministic critic checks emitted.",
      "limitations": "Completion is not substantive validation.",
      "publicationBlocking": true
    },
    "publicationBlockCount": {
      "metricId": "PUBLICATION_BLOCK_COUNT",
      "value": 0,
      "range": "0–unbounded count",
      "formula": "count of active blocking-rule results",
      "interpretation": "Zero is required for automated publication readiness.",
      "limitations": "Zero blockers means machine-checkable editorial gates passed, not that the claim is true.",
      "publicationBlocking": true
    }
  },
  "appliedRules": [
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-BOUND-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "Bounded v7.15 claim fields."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-SOURCE-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "1 confirmatory record(s)."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-COUNTER-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "1 countervailing/limiting record(s)."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-LOCATOR-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "1/1 applicable records have exact locators."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-NOMATCH-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "1 structured NO_MATCH record(s)."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-REL-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "0 unresolved required relationship(s)."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-MECH-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "0 unresolved required mechanism(s)."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-SUBSET-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "Not applicable or no required subset evidence missing."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-CRITIC-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "11/11 deterministic critic checks emitted findings."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-PROV-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "Input hashes and versioned provenance are recorded."
    },
    {
      "ruleId": "AEQ-SCHEMA-001",
      "result": "PASS",
      "basis": "Record produced under the controlled v7.16 schema."
    }
  ],
  "blockingReasons": [],
  "nonBlockingCautions": [
    "NO_MATCH_IS_SEARCH_EVIDENCE_ONLY; it does not make the claim false."
  ],
  "assessmentStatus": "AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE",
  "finalAutomatedState": "AUTOMATED_PUBLICATION_READY",
  "maturity": {
    "automatedAssessment": "NOT_IN_SCOPE",
    "deterministicallyEvaluated": "NOT_IN_SCOPE",
    "evidenceSupported": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
    "corroborated": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
    "verified": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
    "truthStatus": "NOT_ASSESSED",
    "expertApproved": "NOT_ASSESSED",
    "independentlyValidated": "NOT_ASSESSED"
  },
  "doesNotEstablish": [
    "FACTUAL_TRUTH",
    "AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
    "EXPERT_APPROVAL",
    "INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION",
    "CORROBORATION",
    "VERIFICATION",
    "PROBABILITY",
    "CREDIBILITY_SCORE"
  ],
  "provenance": {
    "inputRecordPath": "data/evidence-pilot-v715/records/education-science-knowledge.v1.json",
    "inputRecordSha256": "3477621fae10738c820bb6143ddd869ecdd5c08862c00ee90bf6026c4245935f",
    "sourceRegistrySha256": "520ad2593bae82edd9184e185e3666252b0cf454519cb5a8e1557c2ba0636fb3",
    "subsetRegistrySha256": "04f0168a0c51f89ae4e3ed62d236c205c82372b9de0afe1c0a25a1bc569bb57d",
    "sourceRecordIdentifiers": [
      "source:v715:388ea19e827e867332fc"
    ],
    "ruleVersion": "wsmusings.automated-evidence-quality-engine.v1",
    "schemaVersion": "wsmusings.automated-evidence-assessment.v1",
    "predecessorCommit": "d6ff87ab1311b5dffca1c42b5e68b5758498f327",
    "predecessorTree": "b3ccdb348d3195a0ecee3263eb1ee36d265660fc"
  },
  "outputIdentity": "e9abd9950cc455d507845f9dfbe9a70c78521411816b0f98ac7a69fe57abf663"
}