{
  "schemaVersion": "wsmusings.evidence-pilot.v1",
  "releaseId": "WSM-V7.15-EVIDENCE-PILOT-CANDIDATE-2026-08-24",
  "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T00:00:00Z",
  "counts": {
    "pilotObjects": 5,
    "claims": 5,
    "sources": 8,
    "evidenceRecords": 11,
    "exactLocators": 9,
    "confirmatory": 5,
    "disconfirmatory": 2,
    "mixed": 1,
    "contextOnly": 1,
    "noMatch": 2,
    "relationshipResolved": 0,
    "relationshipUnresolved": 0,
    "mechanismResolved": 0,
    "mechanismUnresolved": 2,
    "eligibleForAutomatedAssessment": 5,
    "eligibleForPublication": 0,
    "deterministicallyEvaluated": 0,
    "evidenceSupported": 0,
    "corroborated": 0,
    "verified": 0
  },
  "records": [
    {
      "objectId": "issue:academic-freedom-campus-pluralism-and-university-governance",
      "objectType": "ISSUE",
      "title": "Academic Freedom, Campus Pluralism & University Governance",
      "route": "/issues/education-science-knowledge/academic-freedom-campus-pluralism-and-university-governance/",
      "k": null,
      "priority": "P1_CRITICAL_RESEARCH_QUEUE",
      "predecessorReadinessState": "NOT_READY",
      "predecessorEvidenceGaps": [
        "LOCATOR_WITHOUT_CLEAR_CLAIM",
        "INSUFFICIENT_CORROBORATION",
        "UNRESOLVED_CLAIM"
      ],
      "claimId": "claim:v715:3a361a24d2d255bb9fb5",
      "claimText": "For faculty at U.S. public universities, the First Amendment protects academic freedom as a constitutional concern, while the application of ordinary public-employee official-duty doctrine to scholarship or teaching remains expressly unresolved by Garcetti.",
      "sourceCount": 2,
      "evidenceRecordCount": 2,
      "keySources": [
        {
          "sourceTitle": "Keyishian v. Board of Regents, 385 U.S. 589 (1967)",
          "direction": "CONFIRMATORY",
          "locator": "CASE_REPORTER_PAGE: 385 U.S. 603"
        },
        {
          "sourceTitle": "Garcetti v. Ceballos, 547 U.S. 410 (2006)",
          "direction": "DISCONFIRMATORY",
          "locator": "CASE_REPORTER_PAGE: 547 U.S. 425"
        }
      ],
      "maturity": {
        "publicationStatus": "NOT_ELIGIBLE",
        "evidenceStatus": "EVIDENCE_ASSIGNED_AWAITING_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "reviewStatus": "NOT_EVALUATED",
        "corroborationStatus": "NOT_CORROBORATED",
        "verificationStatus": "NOT_VERIFIED",
        "researchMaturity": "READY_FOR_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "candidatePlacementIsApproval": false
      },
      "publicationBlockers": [
        "CRITIC_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_INCOMPLETE",
        "RECONCILIATION_INCOMPLETE",
        "REQUIRED_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_ABSENT"
      ],
      "fullRecordUrl": "/research/evidence-pilot/records/issue-academic-freedom-campus-pluralism-and-university-governance/",
      "machineReadableRecordUrl": "/data/evidence-pilot-v715/records/issue-academic-freedom-campus-pluralism-and-university-governance.v1.json"
    },
    {
      "objectId": "education-science-knowledge",
      "objectType": "CATEGORY",
      "title": "Education, Science & Knowledge",
      "route": "/issues/education-science-knowledge/",
      "k": null,
      "priority": "P1_CRITICAL_RESEARCH_QUEUE",
      "predecessorReadinessState": "NOT_READY",
      "predecessorEvidenceGaps": [
        "LOCATOR_WITHOUT_CLEAR_CLAIM",
        "INSUFFICIENT_CORROBORATION",
        "UNRESOLVED_CLAIM"
      ],
      "claimId": "claim:v715:e43e89bfd68a83281ede",
      "claimText": "Federal law assigns the Institute of Education Sciences a mission to provide reliable information about U.S. education condition and progress, access to educational opportunities, and program effectiveness; this mission does not establish the effectiveness of any particular program.",
      "sourceCount": 1,
      "evidenceRecordCount": 2,
      "keySources": [
        {
          "sourceTitle": "Education Sciences Reform Act of 2002, Pub. L. 107-279",
          "direction": "CONFIRMATORY",
          "locator": "STATUTORY_PROVISION: Pub. L. 107-279 § 111(b)(1), 116 Stat. 1945; 20 U.S.C. § 9511"
        }
      ],
      "maturity": {
        "publicationStatus": "NOT_ELIGIBLE",
        "evidenceStatus": "EVIDENCE_ASSIGNED_AWAITING_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "reviewStatus": "NOT_EVALUATED",
        "corroborationStatus": "NOT_CORROBORATED",
        "verificationStatus": "NOT_VERIFIED",
        "researchMaturity": "READY_FOR_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "candidatePlacementIsApproval": false
      },
      "publicationBlockers": [
        "CRITIC_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_INCOMPLETE",
        "RECONCILIATION_INCOMPLETE",
        "REQUIRED_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_ABSENT"
      ],
      "fullRecordUrl": "/research/evidence-pilot/records/education-science-knowledge/",
      "machineReadableRecordUrl": "/data/evidence-pilot-v715/records/education-science-knowledge.v1.json"
    },
    {
      "objectId": "learning-access-finance-governance",
      "objectType": "SUBCATEGORY",
      "title": "Learning Access, Finance & Governance",
      "route": "/issues/education-science-knowledge/subcategories/learning-access-finance-governance/",
      "k": null,
      "priority": "P1_CRITICAL_RESEARCH_QUEUE",
      "predecessorReadinessState": "NOT_READY",
      "predecessorEvidenceGaps": [
        "LOCATOR_WITHOUT_CLEAR_CLAIM",
        "INSUFFICIENT_CORROBORATION",
        "UNRESOLVED_CLAIM"
      ],
      "claimId": "claim:v715:e77bb7ec06e99b23a2e5",
      "claimText": "Covered U.S. postsecondary institutions must provide a net-price calculator under HEA § 132(h), but its result is an estimate that may change and is neither a final aid award nor binding on the institution.",
      "sourceCount": 1,
      "evidenceRecordCount": 2,
      "keySources": [
        {
          "sourceTitle": "2024–2025 Federal Student Aid Handbook, Appendix E: Institutional Reporting and Disclosure Requirements",
          "direction": "CONFIRMATORY",
          "locator": "SECTION: Appendix E, “Net Price Calculator,” HEA § 132(h)(3)–(4); cross-reference Volume 2, Chapter 6"
        },
        {
          "sourceTitle": "2024–2025 Federal Student Aid Handbook, Appendix E: Institutional Reporting and Disclosure Requirements",
          "direction": "MIXED",
          "locator": "SECTION: Appendix E, “Net Price Calculator” disclaimer requirements"
        }
      ],
      "maturity": {
        "publicationStatus": "NOT_ELIGIBLE",
        "evidenceStatus": "EVIDENCE_ASSIGNED_AWAITING_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "reviewStatus": "NOT_EVALUATED",
        "corroborationStatus": "NOT_CORROBORATED",
        "verificationStatus": "NOT_VERIFIED",
        "researchMaturity": "READY_FOR_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "candidatePlacementIsApproval": false
      },
      "publicationBlockers": [
        "CRITIC_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_INCOMPLETE",
        "RECONCILIATION_INCOMPLETE",
        "REQUIRED_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_ABSENT"
      ],
      "fullRecordUrl": "/research/evidence-pilot/records/learning-access-finance-governance/",
      "machineReadableRecordUrl": "/data/evidence-pilot-v715/records/learning-access-finance-governance.v1.json"
    },
    {
      "objectId": "k7:a9740b207405e659e26d",
      "objectType": "INTERSECTIONAL_THEME",
      "title": "Administrative Discretion & Accountability × Cross-System Compounding & Intersectional Amplification × Cumulative & Intergenerational Disadvantage × Data Classification & Measurement Fidelity × Remedy, Retaliation & Access to Redress × Spatial Segregation & Unequal Access × Unequal Resource Allocation & Public Investment",
      "route": "/research/objects/?group=k7%3Aa9740b207405e659e26d",
      "k": 7,
      "priority": "P1_CRITICAL_RESEARCH_QUEUE",
      "predecessorReadinessState": "NEEDS_LOCATOR",
      "predecessorEvidenceGaps": [
        "SOURCE_WITHOUT_LOCATOR",
        "INSUFFICIENT_CORROBORATION",
        "UNRESOLVED_MECHANISM"
      ],
      "claimId": "claim:v715:86457d6f3b68458b9833",
      "claimText": "For covered U.S. federal high-impact AI uses, OMB M-25-21 requires impact assessment, testing, human oversight, and appeal or evidence-assessment processes; those controls do not establish the asserted seven-way interaction among all constituent research issues.",
      "sourceCount": 2,
      "evidenceRecordCount": 3,
      "keySources": [
        {
          "sourceTitle": "OMB Memorandum M-25-21: Accelerating Federal Use of AI through Innovation, Governance, and Public Trust",
          "direction": "CONFIRMATORY",
          "locator": "SECTION: § 4(b)(ii)–(vi), PDF pages 15–16"
        },
        {
          "sourceTitle": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0), NIST AI 100-1",
          "direction": "CONTEXT_ONLY",
          "locator": "SECTION: NIST AI 100-1, Executive Summary and Framework scope"
        }
      ],
      "maturity": {
        "publicationStatus": "NOT_ELIGIBLE",
        "evidenceStatus": "EVIDENCE_ASSIGNED_AWAITING_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "reviewStatus": "NOT_EVALUATED",
        "corroborationStatus": "NOT_CORROBORATED",
        "verificationStatus": "NOT_VERIFIED",
        "researchMaturity": "READY_FOR_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "candidatePlacementIsApproval": false
      },
      "publicationBlockers": [
        "CRITIC_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_INCOMPLETE",
        "RECONCILIATION_INCOMPLETE",
        "REQUIRED_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_ABSENT",
        "UNRESOLVED_REQUIRED_MECHANISM",
        "SUBSET_EVIDENCE_INCOMPLETE"
      ],
      "fullRecordUrl": "/research/evidence-pilot/records/k7-a9740b207405e659e26d/",
      "machineReadableRecordUrl": "/data/evidence-pilot-v715/records/k7-a9740b207405e659e26d.v1.json"
    },
    {
      "objectId": "k2:ac85406ad32a4a9a",
      "objectType": "INTERSECTIONAL_THEME",
      "title": "Institutional Racially Unequal Protection × Racially Unequal Institutional Access",
      "route": "/research/objects/?group=k2%3Aac85406ad32a4a9a",
      "k": 2,
      "priority": "P1_CRITICAL_RESEARCH_QUEUE",
      "predecessorReadinessState": "NEEDS_LOCATOR",
      "predecessorEvidenceGaps": [
        "SOURCE_WITHOUT_LOCATOR",
        "INSUFFICIENT_CORROBORATION",
        "UNRESOLVED_MECHANISM"
      ],
      "claimId": "claim:v715:fb8c554a764e65115f4e",
      "claimText": "Title VI prohibits intentional race, color, or national-origin exclusion from or unequal treatment in federally assisted programs, but Alexander v. Sandoval limits private enforcement by recognizing no private right of action to enforce disparate-impact regulations under Title VI.",
      "sourceCount": 2,
      "evidenceRecordCount": 2,
      "keySources": [
        {
          "sourceTitle": "42 U.S.C. § 2000d (Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964)",
          "direction": "CONFIRMATORY",
          "locator": "STATUTORY_PROVISION: 42 U.S.C. § 2000d; 2023 U.S. Code, Title 42, page 5220"
        },
        {
          "sourceTitle": "Alexander v. Sandoval, 532 U.S. 275 (2001)",
          "direction": "DISCONFIRMATORY",
          "locator": "CASE_REPORTER_PAGE: 532 U.S. 293"
        }
      ],
      "maturity": {
        "publicationStatus": "NOT_ELIGIBLE",
        "evidenceStatus": "EVIDENCE_ASSIGNED_AWAITING_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "reviewStatus": "NOT_EVALUATED",
        "corroborationStatus": "NOT_CORROBORATED",
        "verificationStatus": "NOT_VERIFIED",
        "researchMaturity": "READY_FOR_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT",
        "candidatePlacementIsApproval": false
      },
      "publicationBlockers": [
        "CRITIC_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_INCOMPLETE",
        "RECONCILIATION_INCOMPLETE",
        "REQUIRED_AUTOMATED_ASSESSMENT_ABSENT",
        "UNRESOLVED_REQUIRED_MECHANISM"
      ],
      "fullRecordUrl": "/research/evidence-pilot/records/k2-ac85406ad32a4a9a/",
      "machineReadableRecordUrl": "/data/evidence-pilot-v715/records/k2-ac85406ad32a4a9a.v1.json"
    }
  ],
  "boundaries": {
    "pilotIsWorkflowDemonstration": true,
    "candidateIsApproval": false,
    "publicationEligibilityIsDeploymentAuthorization": false,
    "automatedAssessmentPerformed": false,
    "modelOutputUsedAsEvidence": false
  }
}