{ "canonicalOrdering": "requirementId ascending", "engineVersion": "wsmusings.evidence-completeness-engine.v1", "registryVersion": "7.17.1", "requirements": [ { "applicabilityRule": "Applies to every assessed research object in the bounded pilot.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "CLAIM", "ISSUE", "KNOWLEDGE_OBJECT", "MECHANISM", "STAKEHOLDER_ASSERTION", "STAKEHOLDER_RELATIONSHIP", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT", "GRAPH_EDGE" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": true, "explanation": "The requirement records search coverage without resolving contradiction.", "failureCode": "COUNTEREVIDENCE_REQUIREMENT_UNSATISFIED", "locatorRequirement": "ROLE_DEPENDENT", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": false, "minimumRequiredCount": 1, "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "DISCONFIRMATORY", "MIXED", "CONTEXT_ONLY", "NO_MATCH" ], "requirementId": "ECR-COUNTER-001", "requirementType": "COUNTEREVIDENCE_SEARCH", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "At least one countervailing, limiting, contextual, or structured search record is represented.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "ROLE_DEPENDENT", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": false }, { "applicabilityRule": "Applies to every assessed research object.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "CLAIM", "ISSUE", "KNOWLEDGE_OBJECT", "MECHANISM", "STAKEHOLDER_ASSERTION", "STAKEHOLDER_RELATIONSHIP", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT", "GRAPH_EDGE" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": false, "explanation": "A search result without a qualifying evidence record cannot satisfy evidence existence.", "failureCode": "EVIDENCE_INCOMPLETE", "locatorRequirement": "SEPARATE_REQUIREMENT", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": false, "minimumRequiredCount": 1, "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "CONFIRMATORY", "DISCONFIRMATORY", "MIXED", "CONTEXT_ONLY" ], "requirementId": "ECR-EVIDENCE-001", "requirementType": "EVIDENCE_EXISTENCE", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "At least one non-NO_MATCH evidence record exists.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "REGISTERED_PROVENANCE", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": false }, { "applicabilityRule": "Applies to every non-NO_MATCH evidence record.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "CLAIM", "ISSUE", "KNOWLEDGE_OBJECT", "MECHANISM", "STAKEHOLDER_ASSERTION", "STAKEHOLDER_RELATIONSHIP", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT", "GRAPH_EDGE" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": false, "explanation": "A source citation without its required locator remains incomplete.", "failureCode": "EXACT_LOCATOR_MISSING", "locatorRequirement": "CONTROLLED_TYPE_AND_NONEMPTY_STABLE_VALUE", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": false, "minimumRequiredCount": 1, "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "CONFIRMATORY", "DISCONFIRMATORY", "MIXED", "CONTEXT_ONLY" ], "requirementId": "ECR-LOCATOR-001", "requirementType": "EXACT_LOCATOR", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "Every applicable record contains a controlled exact-locator type and value.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "ANY_REGISTERED_SOURCE", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": false }, { "applicabilityRule": "Applies to pilot intersectionality objects with k >= 2 or an explicit mechanism requirement.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "MECHANISM", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": false, "explanation": "General object evidence cannot substitute for unresolved mechanism evidence.", "failureCode": "MECHANISM_UNRESOLVED", "locatorRequirement": "REQUIRED", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": true, "minimumRequiredCount": 1, "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "CONFIRMATORY" ], "requirementId": "ECR-MECHANISM-001", "requirementType": "MECHANISM_EVIDENCE", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "The required mechanism is explicitly resolved by qualifying evidence.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "REGISTERED_PROVENANCE", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": false }, { "applicabilityRule": "Applies only when a NO_MATCH record is present.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "CLAIM", "ISSUE", "KNOWLEDGE_OBJECT", "MECHANISM", "STAKEHOLDER_ASSERTION", "STAKEHOLDER_RELATIONSHIP", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT", "GRAPH_EDGE" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_APPLICABLE_AND_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": true, "explanation": "NO_MATCH records document bounded search activity and are never positive evidence.", "failureCode": "NO_MATCH_SEMANTICS_INVALID", "locatorRequirement": "NOT_APPLICABLE", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": false, "minimumRequiredCount": 0, "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "NO_MATCH" ], "requirementId": "ECR-NOMATCH-001", "requirementType": "STRUCTURED_NO_MATCH", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "Every NO_MATCH record preserves search scope, strategy, limitations, and non-disconfirmation semantics.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "SEARCH_ATTEMPT", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": false }, { "applicabilityRule": "Applies only when the object declares a required relationship-evidence obligation.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "STAKEHOLDER_RELATIONSHIP", "GRAPH_EDGE", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": false, "explanation": "Computational proximity does not satisfy a relationship-evidence requirement.", "failureCode": "RELATIONSHIP_UNSUPPORTED", "locatorRequirement": "REQUIRED", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": false, "minimumRequiredCount": 1, "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "CONFIRMATORY", "DISCONFIRMATORY", "MIXED" ], "requirementId": "ECR-RELATIONSHIP-001", "requirementType": "RELATIONSHIP_EVIDENCE", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "Every declared required relationship is supported by qualifying relationship evidence.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "REGISTERED_PROVENANCE", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": false }, { "applicabilityRule": "Applies to every assessed research object.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "CLAIM", "ISSUE", "KNOWLEDGE_OBJECT", "MECHANISM", "STAKEHOLDER_ASSERTION", "STAKEHOLDER_RELATIONSHIP", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT", "GRAPH_EDGE" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": false, "explanation": "Affirmative evidence must be explicitly classified as confirmatory.", "failureCode": "CONFIRMATORY_EVIDENCE_REQUIREMENT_UNSATISFIED", "locatorRequirement": "REQUIRED_BY_ECR-LOCATOR-001", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": false, "minimumRequiredCount": 1, "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "CONFIRMATORY" ], "requirementId": "ECR-ROLE-001", "requirementType": "EVIDENTIARY_ROLE", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "At least one CONFIRMATORY record exists; CONTEXT_ONLY and NO_MATCH never substitute.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "REGISTERED_PROVENANCE", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": false }, { "applicabilityRule": "Applies to every non-NO_MATCH evidence record.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "CLAIM", "ISSUE", "KNOWLEDGE_OBJECT", "MECHANISM", "STAKEHOLDER_ASSERTION", "STAKEHOLDER_RELATIONSHIP", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT", "GRAPH_EDGE" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": false, "explanation": "Unregistered or URL-less sources do not satisfy provenance.", "failureCode": "SOURCE_REQUIREMENT_UNSATISFIED", "locatorRequirement": "SEPARATE_REQUIREMENT", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": false, "minimumRequiredCount": 1, "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "CONFIRMATORY", "DISCONFIRMATORY", "MIXED", "CONTEXT_ONLY" ], "requirementId": "ECR-SOURCE-001", "requirementType": "SOURCE_PROVENANCE", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "Every non-NO_MATCH record resolves to a registered source with a canonical URL.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "SOURCE_ID_AND_CANONICAL_URL_IN_SOURCE_REGISTRY", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": false }, { "applicabilityRule": "Applies to pilot higher-order intersectionality objects with k >= 3.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": false, "explanation": "The existence of lower-order objects does not synthesize subset evidence.", "failureCode": "REQUIRED_SUBSET_EVIDENCE_MISSING", "locatorRequirement": "REQUIRED", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": false, "minimumRequiredCount": "ENUMERATED_PROPER_SUBSET_COUNT", "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "CONFIRMATORY", "DISCONFIRMATORY", "MIXED" ], "requirementId": "ECR-SUBSET-001", "requirementType": "REQUIRED_SUBSET_EVIDENCE", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "Every enumerated required proper subset has its own qualifying evidence record.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "REGISTERED_PROVENANCE", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": true }, { "applicabilityRule": "Applies whenever an assessed object has a bounded claim.", "applicableObjectTypes": [ "CLAIM", "ISSUE", "KNOWLEDGE_OBJECT", "MECHANISM", "STAKEHOLDER_ASSERTION", "STAKEHOLDER_RELATIONSHIP", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT", "GRAPH_EDGE" ], "blockingBehavior": "BLOCK_WHEN_UNSATISFIED", "counterevidenceSearchRequirement": false, "explanation": "Evidence assigned to another claim cannot satisfy this object.", "failureCode": "CLAIM_EVIDENCE_TRACEABILITY_UNSATISFIED", "locatorRequirement": "ROLE_DEPENDENT", "mandatory": true, "mechanismRequirement": false, "minimumRequiredCount": 1, "qualifyingEvidenceCategories": [ "CONFIRMATORY", "DISCONFIRMATORY", "MIXED", "CONTEXT_ONLY", "NO_MATCH" ], "requirementId": "ECR-TRACE-001", "requirementType": "CLAIM_EVIDENCE_TRACEABILITY", "requirementVersion": "7.17.1", "satisfactionRule": "Every evidence record names the assessed claim identifier.", "sourceTypeRequirement": "ROLE_DEPENDENT", "subsetEvidenceRequirement": false } ], "schemaVersion": "wsmusings.evidence-requirement-registry.v1", "supportedFutureObjectTypes": [ "CLAIM", "ISSUE", "KNOWLEDGE_OBJECT", "MECHANISM", "STAKEHOLDER_ASSERTION", "STAKEHOLDER_RELATIONSHIP", "INTERSECTIONALITY_OBJECT", "GRAPH_EDGE" ] }